MENU
CLOSE
Request information, we will help you!
Assisted Reproduction clinic in Alicante
+34 965 26 78 90 +34 965 26 78 90
Assisted reproduction clinic in Saint Sebastian
+34 943 328 160 +34 943 328 160
Assisted reproduction clinic in Madrid
+34 914 58 58 04 +34 914 58 58 04
¿Que estás buscando?

Fresh eggs or vitrified eggs: advantages and differences

Home > Blog > Genetic

By Dr. Llanos Medrano.

Llanos Medrano en laboratorio de IVF-Life seleccionando óvulos frescos o vitrificados

Which is better for fertility treatment: fresh or frozen eggs?

The world of assisted reproduction is constantly evolving, with new studies being conducted every day to help patients discover the reason for their infertility and how they can achieve their dream of conceiving a healthy baby. 

The pregnancy rates using fresh or vitrified eggs, from egg donation, are very similar.

In many cases, the only option for couples is to resort to treatment by donation. Requiring egg or sperm donation, or even embryo adoption raises questions about the selection of the gametes and whether vitrification worsens their original quality.

Once the eggs have been joined with the sperm by microinjection, the development is very similar, regardless of whether they are fresh or frozen eggs. 

We spoke to Dr Llanos Medrano, senior embryologist at the international clinic for assisted reproduction IVF-Life Alicante, to answer these questions.

What exactly does egg vitrification consist of?

Cryopreservation consists of freezing gametes or embryos using a medium that increases the viscosity of the sample until it becomes almost solid, thus avoiding the formation of ice crystals, which are very harmful to the cells. 

The vitrification of oocytes or embryos is carried out at a temperature of -196º C, managing to halt the time and therefore the age of the embryos until the moment of implantation.

At IVF-Life, we routinely use the vitrification technique for the oocytes of those patients who undergo social freezing or for surplus donor oocytes. We first prepare the oocyte for vitrification (denudation process) and then cryopreserve them using a media with special characteristics that stop the cellular activity and preserve them for future use.

“Using oocyte denudation, we prepare the egg for either vitrification or fertilisation by ICSI. It consists of using an enzyme and a mechanical process that eliminates the cells that accompany the oocyte.”

Does the use of this technique affect the next steps in the fertility treatment?

Although the oocyte is preserved, the use of this technique results in the destruction of the cells that accompany the oocyte (granulosa) and therefore prevents the oocyte and sperm from recognising each other naturally, making conventional in vitro fertilisation (IVF) impossible. This is why after vitrification, the egg can only be fertilised by sperm microinjection or also known as ICSI.

Fresh eggs, on the other hand, can also be fertilised through IVF, thus allowing nature to decide which sperm should combine with the egg.


What is the difference between fresh and frozen eggs?

As we already mentioned, the vitrification process does not affect the quality of the egg in any significant way. If we want to distinguish the main difference between a fresh egg and a vitrified egg, we have to focus on the viability of the egg itself. In other words, the main difference between a fresh egg and a frozen egg is the initial selection process.

Do fresh eggs guarantee higher pregnancy rates?

When a couple decides to undergo fertility treatment using donate eggs, they can either be fresh or frozen; if they decide on using fresh eggs, the donor will then undergo ovarian stimulation in order to produce an adequate number of eggs to donate to the recipient couple.

On many occasions, there is a high response from the donor, generating surplus eggs, which end up being vitrified. In our laboratories we have a survival rate of around 89%, thanks to the most advanced technology and the knowledge of our staff, we ensure that we obtain the best reproductive outcome.

Do fresh eggs guarantee higher pregnancy rates?

The concept of vitrification and subsequent devitrification of frozen eggs and embryos has changed dramatically in recent years thanks to advances in freezing techniques.

Based on studies conducted and data collected by our fertility clinic during the year of 2021, we can confidently deny that fresh oocytes guarantee higher pregnancy rates. It has been shown that in vitro fertilization rates, embryo division and embryo quality are not affected by vitrification. Pregnancy rates and live newborn rates are also not significantly different.

“Thanks to the research in the laboratory, we have been able to achieve similar implantation or pregnancy rates for embryos obtained from fresh and frozen eggs”.

Is there a difference in the blastocyst formation of a devitrified and a fresh oocyte?

Fact is that the rates are very similar and transferring embryos obtained from fresh or frozen eggs does not affect the implantation or pregnancy rate. However, there is a difference of 8% among the embryos that make it to the blastocyst stage. Why is that?

On the one hand, one of the possible factors causing this discrepancy may be the fact that by using fresh eggs we avoid artificial processes such as vitrification of oocytes or embryos and their subsequent thawing. It is true that any artificial interference in the process will reduce the chances of success of the fertility treatment, even if only minimally.

On the other hand, but no less important, when using fresh eggs the embryologist makes sure to choose the best eggs. Whereas when using vitrified eggs they may not have the same quality and viability as they stem from remaining eggs that were not initially selected for the fresh transfer.

Therefore, if the egg donation treatment is performed with vitrified eggs, it is necessary that these are devitrified first. This implies that some eggs may be lost during the process. To avoid compromising the performance of the cycle, the number of vitrified eggs given to patients is somewhat higher than that given to patients with fresh cycles.

It is therefore essential that when working with vitrified oocytes, the laboratory maintains very high survival rates.

Fresh eggs and vitrified sperm

At IVF-Life we work with fresh oocytes, meaning that we only stimulate the donor once she has been matched with a suitable patient.

When choosing which vitrified gamete to use, we generally prefer using fresh oocytes and cryopreserved sperm. The survival rate of a vitrified oocyte, although very high, is not 100%. For this reason, we always prefer to start with fresh eggs.

This is not the case with semen, as our specialist explains:

“It is true that devitrification may minimally reduce the number of oocytes that have been frozen. However, with sperm it is different. There are millions to choose from. It is also a way to improve the comfort of the couple, as they will not have to return to the clinic to submit their sperm sample, but rather the day they return will already be the day of the embryo transfer. Additionally, this embryo can be frozen, as the survival and pregnancy rates are no different from that of a fresh transfer”.

In conclusion, the use of vitrified donor eggs for assisted reproduction is a safe process. It allows similar results to those obtained with fresh oocytes. However, this technique should only be used in cases in which the quality and viability of the eggs are guaranteed in order to generate viable embryos and, therefore, the birth of healthy babies.

If you have any doubts or find yourself in a particular circumstance, please feel free to contact us through this form or, if you prefer, make an online or face-to-face appointment with us.

Authors

Authors and medical review

Author
Dr. Llanos Medrano

Dr. Llanos Medrano is Laboratory Director and a specialist in Assisted Reproduction at IVF-Life. Her professional career combines clinical laboratory management with research in genetics and embryology, focusing on the optimisation of fertility treatments and embryo quality. She is a member of ESHRE (European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology) and SIERR (Ibero-American Society of Embryology and Reproductive Research), actively participating in international conferences and scientific projects.

¿Do you want to know more?
Dr. Aracil with embryo adoption patient
Embryo adoption
IVF-Life doctor in egg donation consultation
Egg Donation in Spain: IVF with Donor Eggs
Facade of the IVF-Life fertility clinic in Alicante
Cutting-edge technology and assisted reproduction...
Alicante
WE INFORM YOU WITH NO OBLIGATION
Request an appointment with our experts now
I have read and accept the Privacy policy
Privacy Policy

Privacy Policy 

IVF-LIFE, hereby informs you of its privacy policy applied to personal data. The use of the website does not imply that the user must provide any information regarding their identity, and cannot be associated with a specific user by the company. In the event that personal data is provided, this data will be collected and used in accordance with the limitations and rights set out in the aforementioned regulation.  

 WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PROCESSING OF YOUR DATA?  

DATA CONTROLLER: IVF SPAIN ALICANTE S.L.U (hereinafter IVF-Life) 

CIF: B-54973227 

Postal Address: Avenida de Ansaldo, no. 13, 03540, Alicante (Alicante) 

Contact with the Data Protection Officer: dpo@ivf-life-group.com 

DATA CONTROLLER: Instituto Vasco de Fertilidad (hereinafter IVF-Life) 

CIF: B95575874 

Postal Address: Avenida de Tolosa, 71-73, 20018 Donostia / San Sebastián (Spain) 

Contact with the Data Protection Officer: dpo@ivf-life-group.com 

DATA CONTROLLER: IVF Spain Madrid (hereinafter IVF-Life) 

CIF: B 85138113 

Postal Address: C/ de Manuel de Falla, 6-8, 28036 Madrid (Spain) 

Contact with the Data Protection Officer: dpo@ivf-life-group.com  

WHAT TYPE OF DATA DO WE PROCESS?  

Depending on the products, services, or functionalities that you wish to enjoy, we may need to process different types of data. In general, this data will be, depending on the case, the following:  

 - Your identification data: for example: name, surname, language, country from which you interact with us, contact details, etc.  

- Connection, geolocation and navigation data.  

 - Commercial information if you are subscribed to our newsletter.  

- Data about your tastes and preferences.  

WHAT IS THE ORIGIN OF THE DATA?  

The use of certain services or requests addressed to IVF-LIFE are subject to the prior completion of the corresponding form. All the information provided by the User through the forms on the Portal for the above purposes or any other must be truthful.  

To this end, the User guarantees the authenticity of all the data provided and will keep the information provided to IVF-LIFE perfectly up to date so that it corresponds at all times to the User's real situation. In any case, the User will be solely responsible for any false or inaccurate statements made and for any damage caused to IVF-LIFE or third parties because of the information provided.  

By clicking on the "send" button on the corresponding form, the User expressly consents to his/her data being used to send professional communications about his/her query by e-mail or by any other means.  

However, the User may revoke the consent given and oppose the sending of such communications in each of the communications received or by sending them to the address indicated in this legal notice and enabled for this purpose. Likewise, in each of the communications sent, the procedure for opposing the sending of new professional communications shall be expressly indicated.  

Users who provide personal data of other natural persons are obliged to comply, in relation to said data, with all obligations deriving from the data protection regulations in force, and in particular the duty to inform and obtain the consent of the owner of the personal data.  

When we request your personal data to provide access to certain website functionalities, we will mark the required fields to ensure the service can be delivered. 

Please note that if you choose not to provide us with this data, you may not be able to complete your registration as a user or you may not be able to enjoy those services or functionalities.  

For the processing of data, IVF-LIFE adopts the security levels required by current European and national legislation on the Protection of Personal Data. Notwithstanding the above, technical security in a medium such as the Internet is not impregnable and there may be leaks due to the malicious actions of third parties.  

Our services are aimed at people of legal age, in the event that some of our services are specifically aimed at minors, IVF-LIFE will request the consent of parents or guardians for the collection of personal data or, where appropriate, for the automated processing of data as set out in current legislation. If the User is a minor, they are required to have the prior consent of their parents or guardians before proceeding to the inclusion of their personal data in the forms on the Website.  

Initially, your personal data are provided directly by you, but in certain cases they may originate from centres, referring doctors and public health systems with which there is collaboration.  

FOR WHAT PURPOSES DO WE PROCESS YOUR PERSONAL DATA?  

Depending on how you interact with our website, we will process your personal data for the following purposes:  

To deal with requests or requests that you make through the different means incorporated into our website. 

We only process the personal data that is strictly necessary to manage or resolve your request or application.  

For marketing purposes

 To the extent that you subscribe to our newsletter, your personal data will be used for the periodic sending of company newsletters.  

You should remember that you can unsubscribe from the newsletter, at any time and free of charge, by contacting us via the e-mail address of the data controller or by following the instructions that we will provide you with in each of our communications.  

For the management of social networks 

If you follow us or contact us through the different social networks in which we are present, we will process the data that you provide to us through these for the sole purpose of responding to your messages or comments and managing our contact list.  

Usability and quality analysis to improve our services (cookies). 

If you access our platform, we inform you that we will process your browsing data for analytical and statistical purposes, i.e. to understand how users interact with our platform and thus be able to make improvements to it. Likewise, we sometimes carry out quality actions and surveys aimed at finding out the degree of satisfaction of our customers and users and detecting those areas in which we can improve.  

WHAT IS THE LEGAL BASIS FOR PROCESSING YOUR DATA?  

The legal basis that allows us to process your personal data also depends on the purpose for which we process them, so we will find different legal bases under the following purposes:  

Attention to requests for information. 

The legal basis for the processing of your data is the informed consent to respond to queries raised through the website, forms and other means provided, which implies the prior reading and acceptance of these conditions by the interested party.  

Marketing

The legitimate basis for processing your data for marketing purposes is the consent you provide.  

Social networking 

The basis of legitimacy is the informed consent to respond to queries raised through the social network, as well as the time when you follow us and want to be part of our contact list.  

Usability and quality analysis (cookies) 

User consent to the use of cookies.  

HOW LONG WILL WE KEEP YOUR DATA?  

Request for information. We will process your data for as long as it is necessary to deal with your request or request and thereafter 1 year.  

Marketing 

We will process your data until you unsubscribe or cancel your subscription to the newsletter.  

Social media 

We will process your data for as long as it is necessary to deal with your request and for as long as you are a follower of our profile.  

WILL WE SHARE YOUR DATA WITH THIRD PARTIES?  

 Personal data will not be transferred or communicated to third parties, except: legal obligation, we obtain your express consent, or we understand that there is a legitimate interest on our part, which will be duly communicated to you.  

 However, we inform you that we are present in the following social networks: Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram and YouTube, to keep our followers informed regarding the company's news and services.  

 You can access these social networks voluntarily and through the links available on the website itself or by accessing directly and on your own from your browser or installed app.  

You should know that this website is not responsible for the use of the data that these social networks may make. However, when these data are generated in the social network and derive from an interaction with our website, we will not be held responsible for the use of such data.  

In order to consent to our transfer from this website and the processing of your data, you should carefully read the privacy policy of the social network you wish to access:  

Facebook: Facebook Privacy Policy

Instagram: Instagram Privacy Policy

LinkedIn: Linkedin Privacy Policy

YouTube: Youtube Privacy Policy

Spotify: Spotify Privacy Policy

 

In this way, before clicking on the logos of the SS. RR. present on our website, you can inform yourself and make a redirection with prior knowledge of the processing of your data and on a voluntary basis.  

Other technological services:  

- WhatsApp: WhatsApp Privacy Policy  

 - Companies of the "IVF LIFE Group" on the legal basis of consent or legitimate interest: Instituto Vasco de Fertilidad S.L.U., with NIF B95575874 and address at Avda Tolosa, 71-73 Donostia (Gipuzkoa), and IVF Spain Madrid S.L., with NIF B85138113 and address at Calle Manuel de Falla, 6-8, 28036 Madrid.  

WHAT ARE YOUR RIGHTS WHEN YOU PROVIDE US WITH YOUR DATA? 

 We undertake to respect the confidentiality of your personal data and to guarantee you the exercise of your rights.  

 You may exercise them free of charge by sending us an e-mail to our address above, simply by providing proof of identity, the reason for your request and the right you wish to exercise.  

 If we consider it necessary in order to identify you, we may ask you for a copy of a document proving your identity. In particular, regardless of the purpose or the legal basis on which we process your data, you have the right to:  

Ask us for access to the data we hold about you.  

Ask us to rectify the data we already hold about you. Please note that by actively providing us with your personal information in any way, you warrant that it is true and accurate and you undertake to notify us of any changes or modifications to it.  

Ask us to delete your data to the extent that they are no longer necessary for the purpose for which we need to process them as we have previously informed you, or to the extent that we no longer have the legitimacy to do so.  

Ask us to restrict the processing of your data, which means that in certain cases you may ask us to temporarily stop processing the data or to keep it longer than necessary when you may need it. If you have given us your consent to process your data for any purpose, you also have the right to withdraw your consent at any time.  

To receive the personal data concerning you that you have provided to us in a structured, commonly used and machine-readable form and to transfer it to another data controller.  

Moreover, where the processing of your data is based on our legitimate interest, you also have the right to object to the processing of your data.  

Finally, we inform you of your right to lodge a complaint with the relevant data protection supervisory authority, with the Spanish Data Protection Agency.  

CHANGES TO THE PRIVACY POLICY

We may change the information contained in this Privacy Policy from time to time. If we do so, we will notify you by various means through the Platform, or we will notify you at your email address when the change in question is significant to your privacy, so that you can review the changes, assess them and, where appropriate, object to or unsubscribe from any service or functionality.  

INFORMATION ABOUT COOKIES  

We use cookies and similar devices to facilitate your navigation on the Platform, to know how you interact with us and, in certain cases, to be able to show you advertising based on your browsing habits. Please read our Cookie Policy to learn more about the cookies and similar devices we use, their purpose and other information of interest. 

More info
More info Clinics